Title: GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK DISTRICT Engineering Group of the Geological Society Fie
1GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICTEngineering Group of the Geological
Society Field visit 23rd 25th June 2005
- John C Cripps
- Department of Civil and Structural Engineering
- University of Sheffield
j.c.cripps_at_sheffield.ac.uk Tel 0114 222 5054
2GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
Peak District National Park
- Geography
- Geology
- Engineering geology
- Land instability
- Quarrying
- Mining
- Dams and reservoirs
- Other issues
3GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
Peak District National Park
- Created in 1951
- First National Park in UK (10 in 1950s)
- Upland areas of scenic value
- Mainly rural with farming, forestry, quarrying,
water catchment and tourism - Area of 1438 square km (555 square miles)
- Population of 38,000 residents
- Mostly in villages, but also some towns (eg
Bakewell) - Buxton Whaley Bridge and Glossop excluded.
4GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
Peak District National Park
- 30 million visits per year
- Popularity surpassed only by Mt Fuji National
Park, Japan - 17 million people live within 60 miles of park
- Packhorse tracks
- Roads Toll roads in early 19th C A6, A621,
A625, A57, A628, A635 - Railways Trans Pennine routes, now Sheffield
Manchester via Edale, Buxton
5GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
Peak District National Park Authority
- Local Planning and Mineral Planning Authorities
- Representatives of County, District and Borough
Councils and central Government - Funding about 50 from Government grants, 50
from local taxes and charges - Aim to promote sustainable development and
conservation - Improve the quality of life without consuming
limited resources - Aim to balance needs of locals, visitors and
national interests (eg in terms of minerals
supplies).
6GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OFTHE PEAK
DISTRICT
Geology
7GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
- At southern end of the Pennine Hills
- Sequence of mainly Carboniferous rocks with
Permo-Triassic and later rocks to W, E and S - North- south trending anticlinal structure
8GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
- Derbyshire dome formed from re-excavated platform
area - Subsidiary N-S tending folds on limbs of
anticline - Faulted contacts to west, gentle unconformity to
east - East-west and ENE-WSW trending faulting
- Mineral rakes and pipes follow same trends
9GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
- Oldest formations are Lower Carboniferous
- Base not exposed boreholes show at least 500m
limestones - Basement consists of cleaved lower Palaeozoic
volcanic rocks.
10GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
- Carboniferous Limestone (gt500m)
- Limestones mainly thickly bedded bioclastic
deposits with crinoids, corals, bivalves,
brachiopods with well defined bedding. - Interbedded clay wayboards due to volcanic
activity - Some fine grained, dark coloured limestone formed
in deep water conditions - Edges of platform area fringed by fossiliferous,
rubbley, reef limestones. - Some reef formation in the platform area
11GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
12GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
- Reef Limestone (Winnats Pass, near Castleton)
13GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
- Igneous rocks (lavas, tuffs, dolerite and basalt)
Cavedale lava
14GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
- Millstone Grit Formation gt900m
- The lower parts of this sequence consist of fine
grained, dark coloured shale mudrocks lying
unconformably over the limestone - In placed there are beds of siltstone, limastone
and sideritic mudstone - This sequence passes laterally or upwards into
the Mam Tor Beds or the Shale Grit - These consist of interlayered greywacke sandstone
and mudstones in a rhythmic, turbiditic sequences - The Shale Grit is overlain by a sequence of thick
coarse grained arkosic sandstones Kinderscout,
Chatsworth Grits interbedded with thick beds of
shale.
15GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
- BGS Holiday Geology Leaflet Satellite image
- Brown Coarse grained sst
- Green Shales over lain by sandstones and shales
- Blue Limestone
- Red Igneous
- Yellow - Faults
- Grey - Urban
16GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
- BGS Holiday Geology Leaflet Satellite image
- Brown Coarse grained sst
- Green Shales over lain by sandstones and shales
- Blue Limestone
- Red Igneous
- Yellow - Faults
- Grey - Urban
17GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
- Chatsworth Sst, Mam Tor Beds Edale Shale
18GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
- The lower Carboniferous sequence is overlain by
the Lower, Middle and Upper Coal Measures - Small area of Coal Measures in west of Peak
District, but important east and west of area - Cyclothemic sequence of mudstones, siltstones,
sandstones and coal seams. -
19GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
- Besides coal gansister, seatearth and
ironstone are also present and exploited - There are about 30 cycles, representing
variable water level conditions in a deltaic
environment. - Not all parts of the typical cyclothem are
present.
20GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
- Presumably the Peak District was overlain by
some kilometres of later deposits - Uplift in Tertiary times
- Landscape is closely linked to the geology
- Hydrothermal mineralisation galena,
fluorspar, barites, zinc blende - Mainly in limestone and capped by shales and
igneous rocks
21GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
- Permian consists of sequence of marls and
dolomitic limestones formed in inland basins. - There is a basal conglomerate in places and
reddening of the top of the Carboniferous near
the unconformity Landscape is closely linked to
the geology. - To the east, the sequence continues with Triassic
Sherewood Sst and Mercia Mst, which were formed
under hot dry terrestrial conditions
22GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
Quaternary
- Formation of head, solifluction deposits,
hill peat and some loess - Lake District erratics present in west of Peak
district and Pennine Drift in Derwent Valley - Valley bulging and scarp cambers
- Landsliding of over-steepened slopes
associated with periods of high rainfall - Alluvium deposited in river valleys
23GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
Distinctive Landscapes White Peak
- Dissected plateau with dales and rolling
countryside - Area characterised grazing pastureland surrounded
by limestone walls - Some coppices and trees on steeper valley sides
land - Drainage mainly underground but some rivers
developed where igneous rocks and mudrocks impede
vertical drainage - Mineral workings for galena, fluorspar etc, shale
and limestone - In past also marble, chert etc
24GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
25GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
26Bluejohn Calcite
GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
Fluorspar Galena
27GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
Dark Peak
- Main Plateau formed on Kinderscout Grit and other
sandstone units - Peat covered moorland with tors sheep grazing
and grouse shooting - Steep sided valleys forming areas of woodland and
pasture - Thick sequences of shales eroded into major
valleys (eg Derwent Valley) - Easterly and westerly dipping sandstone beds give
rise to dramatic scarp features know locally as
edges - Quarrying for millstones and grinding stones and
building stone
28GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
- Dark Peak scenery Gritstone edges with heather
and bracken covered moors
29GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
30GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
Engineering geology
- Landslides
- Dams and Reservoirs
- Quarrying
- Mining
- Industrial legacy
31GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
Landsliding
- Most are rotational in form
- Subsidiary parts have translational slides and
rockfall activity - Many in steep valleys formed in sandstone and
shale sequences of Millstone Grit - Upper part of slope (scarp) in sandstone and
lower part in mudrocks - Some formed in limestone mudrock sequences
32GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
- Landslidding and rockfallss Significant problem
for roads eg A625, A57, A628, dams and reservoirs
(eg Ladybower) where instability easily reactived - Some solifluction deposits
Some rockfalls on steep limestone and sandstone
cliffs and edges, especially where over-steepened
by cambering, erosion or exc-avation (eg A57, as
shown)
33GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
- Examples of landslides
- Mam Tor
- Alport Castles
34GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
Noteable landslides
- Mam Tor led in 1978 to the closure of the
A625 - Ashop Valley need for frequent maintenance
to the A57 - Alport Castles reputedly largest inland
landslide in UK - Longdendale Valley Barnsley to Manchester
railway line (now closed) - Rushup Edge and Edale Valley Many
impressive landslides
35GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
36GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
37GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
- Mam Tor Back scarp in Mam Tor Beds, Damage to
road and Movements vectors (0.5m/yr)
38GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
- Mam Tor Blacketlay Barn (pushed over in 1983)
Seep-ages on toe area, Information board
39GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
Dams and Reservoirs
- High rainfall and present of lower permeability
mudrocks gives rise to good prospects for water
storage - Large cities adjacent to and south of Pennines
supplied - Noteable structures include the Derwent Dams
(Howdon, Derwent and Ladybower Reservoirs),
Carsington Reservoir pump storage system, and
tens of smaller dams
40GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
- Derwent Dam 1916
- Masonry.
- Valley bulge features
- Cut-off trench 12m deep by 2m wide plus wing
walls
41GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
- Ladybower Dam 1944
- Embankment
- Cut-off up to 76m
42GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
- Major failure of Dale Dyke Dam, Sheffield in
1864, resulted in 270 deaths, the destruction of
798 houses and much other damage. - Failure of Carsington Dam in 1984, when nearing
completion
43GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
44GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
- Carsington
- Shale fill with limestone drainage layers
- Loss of strength
- Compaction shears
- Solifluction shears
- Pyrite oxidation
- Acid generation
- 2 asphixiated in manhole
- Concrete attack
45GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
- Sheffield flood 1864
- -Dale Dyke dam near Bradfield
- - Embankment 95ft with puddle clay core
279 killed Damage 327,000
46GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
Mining
- Lead important since Roman times, with a peak of
production in early 18th C - Minerals galena, zinc blende, fluorspar, calcite
- 10,000 employed in industry at peak
- Last mine reportedly closed in 1938
- Noteable presence of lead tolerant plants on
rakes and tips - Danger to animals due to poisoning and collapse
47GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
Galena Odin Rake (mineral vien removed by mining
Mining
Mineralised veins in Peak District
48GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
Mining
- Worked by surface and underground methods with
extensive use of pumping and drainage soughs to
control water - Some processing of old tips, now finished
49GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
Fluorspar - Milldam Mine, Gt Hucklow Open
workings
50GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
Fluorspar
- 98 of present UK production from Peak District
- Major surface (eg Longstone Edge) and
underground workings (eg Milldam Mine) - New permissions linked to restoration but some
small - scale workings tolerated
- Mineral processing at Cavendish Mill, Stoney
Middleton. - Castleton area famous for
- Bluejohn which is worked into
- very attractive decorative vases,
- bowls and jewellery
51GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
Milldam Mine Backfilling of workings
52Cavendish Mill near Stony Middleton,
DerbysFluorspar processing waste
These lagoons provide a body of water in an area
where such features are rare and benefit ecology
53GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
Other resources
- Fireclay
- Marble
- Chert
- Oil and gas
- Silica sand
- Water local wells and Buxton water
54GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
Quarrying
- Limestone 6.1 million tonnes in 1993 -
roadstone and concrete aggregate, iron, steel and
chemical industries, agriculture and cement (2
major works) - Sandstone about 12 small quarries - now for
building stone - Basalt and dolerite eg Carlton Hill subsequently
used for landfill - Pressure to reduce limestone production
- Restoration of quarrying sites
-
55GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
Limestone Mine at Middleton by Wirksworth
Surface subsidence effects
56GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
Quarrying
Crich Hope
Locations of limestone quarries
57GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
Hope Valley Cement Works
- Opened in 1929, modernised in 1960s to use dry
process with heat exchange tower - Works on unconformity between Carboniferous
Limestone and Edale Shale - Fuelled by coal which is brought in by train, now
burning tyres and other replacement fuels - Present planning permission envisages
continuation to 2032 - Recent planning permission to increase production
to supply south east England by rail, requires
construction of new sidings
58GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
Restoration plans
Jerrico plan for restoration (1943) Restored
shale pits now landscaped and flooded Recently
waste material landscaped and planted to conceal
entrance to quarry Present plan envisages a
steep-sided valley feature with grassy slopes,
scree and trees Some faces used in restoration
blasting trails, along with faces at Tunstead
Quarry
59GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
Restoration plans
Jerrico plan for restoration (1943) Restored
shale pits now landscaped and flooded Recently
waste material landscaped and planted to conceal
entrance to quarry Present plan envisages a steel
sided valley feature with grassy slopes, scree
and trees Some faces used in restoration
blasting trails, along with faces at Tunstead
Quarry
60GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OFTHE PEAK
DISTRICT
Hope Cement Works
61GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
Hope Quarry Jellico Plan (1943) for 1993
62GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OFTHE PEAK
DISTRICT
Hope Quarry present restoration plans
63GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
Eldon Hill Quarry
Operated by RMC and supplied aggregates. In a
prominent hill-side location Company plans for
restoration, which envisaged small extension to
area of extraction, were rejected by
planners Restoration consists of landscaping of
plant area and screening of quarry with planting
and creation of a lagoon A very high quarry face
remains, with obvious problems in terms of
long-term hazard and poor appearance
64GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
Eldon Hill Quarry
65- The Reclamation of Limestone
- Quarries by Landform Simulation
- 1979 Selective blasting pioneered by Neil
Humphries - 1987 the Limestone Research Group (LRG) carried
out initial trials of restoration blasting - 1988 DoE commissioned LRG Landform
Replication as a Technique for the
Reclamation of Limestone Quarries - 1993 Geoffrey Walton Practice assessed and
monitored the stability of the rock faces and
screes - 1998 DETR commissioned ECUS to assess the
success of trial sites created by LRG at
Hope and Tunstead Quarries - 2003 MIRO (ODPM) commissioned University of
Sheffield to report on reclamation of hard rock
quarries
66Environmental Impacts of Quarries
- Landscape Design to Reduce Impact
67The Reclamation of Limestone Quarries by
Landform Simulation
- Experimental Restoration Blasting
- rock faces
- scree
- grassy slopes
- buttress features
- trees
-
68Trees Headwall Buttress Grass slope
- Landform created by
- restoration blasting
Model daleside
Trees Buttress Headwall Scree Grass slope
69Experimental restoration blasting
- Original rock face
- Rock features (eg buttress/headwall)
- Planted trees
- Vegetated cover material
Blastpile (scree) Toe of original rock face
70Trial site RB14
Hope Quarry
71RB14 Hope Quarry Date of blast 1990
Face height 25-30m Cover material over
scree rejects Face length 90m Hydroseeded
1990 Tree planting 1990/91
72RB8/9 Tunstead Quarry Date of blast 1989
Face height c.20m Cover material over
scree Face length 150m Hydroseeded 1990 Tree
planting 1990
73Tunstead Quarry restoration blast faces rock
falls
RB14 Open factures at top of faces Blast
fractured rock in RB5
74Tunstead Quarry restoration blast faces rock
falls
Face parallel open joints in headwalls and
buttresses
RB15 RB4
75Tunstead Quarry restoration blast faces rock
falls
RB4 (corner buttress). (14/06/00) .
RB8/9 (21/11/98)
76Landscape
Foreground viewpoint
-
RB14 Hope Quarry
77(No Transcript)
78(No Transcript)
79(No Transcript)
80(No Transcript)
81(No Transcript)
82- Vegetation cover sparce due to rabbit grazing
-
83 84Hindered by lack of soil and aftercare
85Some success at Hope
86GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
Legacy of Mining and Industry
-
- Acid Mine drainage
- Contaminated land
- Industrial dereliction
- Rock slope stability
87GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
Acid Mine Drainage
May not be acid, depending on neutralisation of
acid in rock mass Main problems are ochre
precipitation, de-oxygenation and heavy metal
mobilisation Due to oxidation of pyrite which can
be aided by bacteria Pyrite is a common
constituent of dark coloured mudrocks Rising
groundwaters gives rise to more problems
88- Acid mine drainage waters
- FeS2 O H2 O ---gt H2 SO2 Fe oxides
- H2 SO2 CaCO3 ---gt Ca SO4 H2O CO2
- May not be acid
- Heavy metals mobilised, deleted O2 and ochre
-
Pyrite (fools gold) in slate Commonly occurs in
dark coloured shales and mudstones (black and
very fine grained)
89GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OFTHE PEAK
DISTRICT
- Significant issue at Mam Tor, Carsington and
discharges from flooded coal workings on the
exposed coalfield. - Reduced shear strength of mudrock due to rapid
breakdown - Production of gypsum leading to the widening of
joints, may lead to foundation heave. - Production of CO2 leading to deaths of workers
at Carsington
90GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OFTHE PEAK
DISTRICT
Carsington
91Acid Mine Drainage
- Lower water table during mining
- Availability of oxygen
- Water flow through flooded workings picks up
oxidation products - Continued oxidation of pyrite
- Oxidation assisted by sulphate reducing bacteria
- Groundwater rise leads to pollution to
groundwaters and surface waters
92Pollution to River Drone
- Ochre pollution in streams
- Rising groundwaters in old mines flush out
oxidation products
93Pollution to River Drone
Lower pH and choking of biota
94Limb Brook Seepage number 1 (2004)Tributary to
R. Sheaf
95GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OFTHE PEAK
DISTRICT
Rock slopes in urban development sites (former
quarries)
96GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OFTHE PEAK
DISTRICT
Former quarries in Sheffield, now used as retail
areas
97GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
- Solly Street, Sheffield
- Students evacuated
Due to collapse of retaining wall during
demolition of factory
98Failure of road cutting in dipping sandstone -
mudstone sequence
99GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
Land instability at Bolsover
- Magnesian Limestone escarpment
- Mining subsidence ? Leaking pipes ?
- Groundwater rise ? Natural instability
100GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT
Land instability at Bolsover Loss of 4 houses
plus damage to castle and houses
101Mining subsidence main causes with collapse of
pillar and stall workings
- Void migration
- Pillar collapse
- Floor and/or roof punching
102Void migration (main process of collapse)
- Old gallery seen in open cast coal mine
Formation of crown hole
103Collapses in Barnsley Seam
Crown hole
104- House in Chesterfield affected by subsidence
Failure of one pillar by collapse or punching
puts additional load on adjacent pillars which
may fail leading to subsidence of an area of the
surface (see later for effects of removal of
support)
105Sheaf Street, Bus station and Railway Station
Recorded old coal workings
- Old mine workings underlie Hallam
University, Bus Station Ponds Forge and Don
Valley at various depths . Workings stretch right
across the area north (to right) of the Station
106Contaminated land at the Avenue site,
Chesterfield former coke/gas works with tar
logoon
107Orgreave coke works c1980
-
- Waste from gas and
- coke works
- Smog (smoke fog)
- Acid rain
108Aspects of reclamation and restoration of
brownfield sites
- Orgreave colliery and coke plant (c. 1980)
109Colliery spoil disposal
Aspects of reclamation and restoration of
brownfield sites
Combustion Acid water
drainage Lack of vegetation Ugly
110Burnt Shale in Spoil Tip
111Excavation and backfill
112Open casting
113Diversion of River Rother
Aspects of reclamation and restoration of
brownfield sites
114Orgreave Lined landfill
115Orgreave restoration plan commercial,
residential and leisure development including
lakes and walks
116Welbeck landfill and reclamation
Income from waste disposal providing means to
reclaim area
117GEOLOGY AND ENGINEERING GEOLOGY OF THE PEAK
DISTRICT